Want to get your business featured in Anthill?

img

Murdoch and Calacanis hatch separate plans to shut out Google

November 11, 2009 | By Paul Ryan

Here’s an interesting idea from Mahalo founder and Silicon Valley insider, Jason Calacanis. A couple of weeks ago on This Week in Startups, he floated a strategy that would enable Microsoft to seize a chunk of search market share from Google and the big media companies to make more revenue from their digital content.

Calacanis suggested that Microsoft should offer the top 10 media companies 50 percent more than Google currently pays them in content aggregation licensing fees if they block Google from indexing their content (which Google freely allows anyone to do) and have it indexed only by Microsoft’s Bing search engine.

As Calacanis says in his email newsletter:

So, for a moment, imagine a world where Bing could say in their TV commercials:

“Want to search the New York Times, Wall Street Journal, USA Today and
3,894 other newspapers and magazine?”

“Well, then don’t go to Google because they don’t have them!”

“Go to Bing, home of quality content you can trust!”


News Corporation chairman Rupert Murdoch may not be interested in jumping into bed with Microsoft just to stick it to Google, which he has referred to as a “kleptomaniac” and a “parasite”. But in an interview with Sky News Australia earlier this week he indicated that he is partial to the idea of barring Google and other search engines from indexing his content as a tactic designed to encourage readers to pay for News Corp. content online. He also flagged his inclination to sue anyone reproducing News Corp. content without permission.

While Murdoch has enough clout to shake things up, it is testament to Google’s success that it becomes the target of powerful people such as Murdoch when what they are actually raging against is the internet itself and the havoc is has wrought on their once buoyant commercial vessels. Or, as one commenter over on Mumbrella remarked, “Poor guy, all he wants is those people OFF HIS LAWN!!”

By the way, Google has responded by saying that it has no intention of indexing publishers against their wishes.

Here’s the full Sky News interview with Murdoch (it’s 37 minutes).

Want to turn your secret skills into a brand?

Want an ad like this?

Learn the Five Step Sequence to becoming a Key Person of Influence and become a highly valued (and did we mention HIGHLY PAID) person in your industry Learn from five of Australia’s most inspiring minds.

Melbourne: 1 June 2012
Sydney: 30 June 2012
Normal Price: $39.

Being GOOD at what you do is no longer enough in the new economy. Spend ONE DAY learning from THE BEST. Click here to get your ticket.

  • Ben

    There seems to be a lot of talk from Rupert. I mean have you had a look at the “quality” content his empire creates? The Sun-Herald, Fox News etc. If you couldn’t find this crap when you search Google news then so be it. The world will move on.

    Rupert, build your walled garden, curl up and die. Can’t wait for the new breed of media, blogs and social interaction just around the corner.

    [Reply]

  • http://www.eventarc.com Scott Handsaker

    The suggestion from Calcanis sounds anti-competitive? He is a sensational self-promoter (I wish I was half as good), but I tend to take his proclamations with a grain or 2 of salt.

    Rupert on the other hand is beyond help. Reminds me of that song….

    “The old, grey mare she ain’t what she used to be…aint what she used to be….”

    [Reply]

    Paul Ryan Reply:

    Anti-trust occurred to me, too. But you could never get the big media companies to agree on this anyway. They’re still trying to play it all on their turf.

    [Reply]

  • http://startupmelbourne.com/ Erik Unger

    Just lean back and enjoy the show. Murdoch has from an old and thrashy Gozilla.

    I don’t use _any_ of his media and don’t miss anything :)

    [Reply]

  • http://www.baseestate.com Craig

    Calcanis idea is fine until the publishers discover that after blocking Google and going exclusively with Bing their traffic is reduced by 50%. Are they willing to take that trade off? I don’t think so.

    [Reply]

    Paul Ryan Reply:

    TechCrunch thinks that blocking Google would lose WSJ.com 25% of its traffic.

    http://www.techcrunch.com/2009/11/09/if-the-wsj-com-says-goodbye-to-google-it-will-also-say-goodbye-to-25-percent-of-its-traffic/

    [Reply]

blog comments powered by Disqus

Find Us on facebook

Latest Video

Waiting for the great leap forward? I think it’s already here [VIDEO]

Throw away your keyboard. Discard your mouse. All you need to do to control your computer is wave your hands about. No instruction manual needed, just a teeny, tiny device that reads your hand motions. Really. The revolution in human-computer interaction just took a massive leap forward.

More>>

Latest Comments

Ant Mart

Anthill Amabassadors

Tech & Innovation

Sponsored by AusIndustry

AusIndustry is a specialist program delivery division within the Department of Innovation, Industry, Science and Research.

More>>

thumb

Growth & Export

Sponsored by How to become a Key Person of Influence

Key People enjoy a special status in their chosen field because they are well connected, well known, well regarded and highly valued.

More>>

thumb

Marketing & Media

Sponsored by Google

What do you know about Google AdWords? This hub was developed to answer the questions you already have, and those you haven’t thought yet to ask.

More>>

thumb

Anty-Climax

Sponsored by Antmart

It’s a group buying site specifically created for entrepreneurs and business builders.

More>>

thumb

Upcoming Events

MAY
29

Want more leads and customers? Half day event to get big outcomes from a little budget.

Have you ever wondered… Why every industry has only a few businesses that thrive and get more leads? And they don’t suffer from cash flow problems or lack of leads, even when there is an ‘economic downturn’. They don’t have to ‘push’ or make stacks of cold calls.

More>>

MAY
22

WEBINAR: How to turn your knowledge into products… and build a global empire in your underpants!

This webinar is all about how to unlock your valuable industry knowledge and turn it into a product. It’s about how to increase the value of your business and take control of its future.

More>>